Team Sports are to Blame for the Decline of US Dominance
By Athletes' Acceleration | August 20th, 2008
I’m not one to buckle under social pressure. In fact,
its usually just the opposite.
But the responses to yesterday’s email were good
enough to get me to modify my description of the
state of US Athletics.
So I won’t say it’s collapsed, but it’s not what it
once was. If you get better and I stay the same,
that’s equal to me being on the decline.
It’s just a matter of semantics.
I’ll cover some of the other disputes with my
argument down the road.
But to today’s discussion:
In the US, we are obsessed with team sports. More
specifically Football, Basketball, Soccer and
Baseball.
More specifically, some parents/adults are
obsessed with professional team sports. So they
try to live their dreams by funneling their kids
into those mainstream sports as early as possible.
Then many of them live the dream that their kid is
going to ‘make it’.
I can’t count how many thousands of emails I’ve gotten
over the years that say something like ‘My 13 year
old son is a football player’, or ‘My 11 and 12 year
old soccer players’.
Really?
After my last email Ron brought up a great point:
“Basketball, football and baseball siphons off a
tremendous amount of track and field talent in
the U.S. In Jamaica there’s no football or
basketball to take away the speedy athletes. I
think the main lack of U.S. depth of high jumpers,
long jumpers and triple jumpers is that they are
playing basketball at some level. A lot of
average-talent basketball players could be elite
track and field athletes if they were
“cross-trained’. The kids play basketball all
year now and aren’t recruited into T&F. Can you
imagine Lebron James in the TJ? For example the
U.S. women’s pole vault champ was a former
basketball player.”
He’s absolutely right.
I lose more talented athletes (especially girls)
to 12 month a year soccer than I even want to think
about. It’s a joke.
So many kids and parents cling to the ‘athletic
scholarship/going pro’ dream that they completely
miss the fact their kid could excel at another
sport.
I only ran track because I had nothing to do in
the spring. I was living the basketball dream
until I started abusing kids on the track.
I was a marginal basketball player but a Division I
scholarship track athlete.
And I can name dozens of others in the same boat.
And with Title IX, they practically throw scholarships
at female athletes. When I was in college there
were guys on my team who were NCAA All Americans
who weren’t on full rides. But women who couldn’t
score in duel meets against bum teams were. Sad.
(Save your Title IX comments, I get why it exists.)
If more mediocre basketball players became jumpers,
we’d have more medals in those events.
If more mediocre football players became throwers,
we’d have more medals in those events.
If more kids went into swimming….
…you get the idea.
We don’t lack talent here in the US. As coaches
and parents we lack objectivity.
Instead of being smart and giving young athletes
a diet of multilateral training during the
developmental years (9-14), one that allows them to peak
higher once they do decide to pick a focus, they
specialize kids early. And then wonder why kids
burn out or don’t perform like they should.
But I’ll get into that soon enough.
Now, since people in this country only care about
revenue sports (football, basketball, baseball and
to a lesser extent soccer) the individual sports
get no love. In the rest of the world, that isn’t
necessarily the case.
So the blame there goes to the piss poor business
and marketing ability of your swimmings, track and
fields, gymnastics, etc.
Until these fringe sports do a better job of making
people know that they exist, or care, athletes in
this country will stick to what they know.
You can’t blame the NFL or NBA for being good at
marketing and promoting their product.
But it’s also the reason we’re not as dominant on
the international stage. Because there are about
357 medals available in swimming, but only one
in basketball.
Of course, in this country people don’t care about
that as long as their kid makes varsity football
as a freshman or their daughter makes the club
soccer team that requires a 12 month commitment.
At the end of the day, part of the reason American
sports dominance on the international stage is
falling off rests in the average American’s obsession
with professional team sports and their inability
to comprehend that countless other sports actually
exist.
And that they are fun, exciting and take considerable
talent.
To your success,
Latif Thomas
NOTE: I felt compelled to respond
to a couple of the responses to
this post. Of course, I’ll be
covering these ideas later.
Alan (#4): Yes. I do blame parents for wanting
their kids to specialize early. Ignorance is not
an excuse for bad parenting. Their kids are not
going to be A-Rod, a Manning or Michael Jordan.
To put that idea in their kid’s head or allow it
to fester in their own is, in my opinion (and all
the other professional strength and conditioning
coaches I know) akin to child abuse.
Basing theirchild’s youth sport choice on their
money making potential only further proves my
point that parents are a danger to their own
children.
A more appropriate idea (not that it is) would be
to have their children run track or another ‘lesser’
sport. They have a much better chance of getting
an athletic scholarship (especially females) in
those sports than in basketball, soccer, football,
etc.
Michael (#5): I don’t disagree with you. And I
don’t think you should prevent an 11 year old from
playing soccer if he loves it. But you should
prevent him from playing it 12 months per year.
And you should have him play other sports as well.
He’ll be a better soccer player if he plays 3-6
months per year than he would if he played year
round. Young kids need multilateral training, not
sport specific repetitive motions.
------------------------------
Spread the Word:
------------------------------











